Vito Scalletta is probably the most popular character from the Mafia franchise. Seeing him referenced in Mafia: The Old Country would make a lot of fans very happy.
Still, because Mafia: The Old Country is a prequel to the Mafia games, there is no guarantee that he will be around. There are some clues as to what may be there, but we know enough to judge whether Vito will be in the newest Mafia game.
Will Vito Scalletta Cameo In Mafia: The Old Country?

No, Vito Scaletta is not in Mafia: The Old Country. The game takes place in Sicily during the early 1900s, specifically around 1905, which is before Vito was even born.
Mafia: The Old Country focuses on the growth of organized crime in Sicily and follows a new main character named Enzo Favara. The story explores Enzo’s path from living in poverty to joining the Cosa Nostra, while also diving into the early history of the Mafia.
While Mafia: The Old Country might include nods to the larger Mafia universe or tease events that happen later in the timeline, it is still a standalone story set in a different time than the games that feature Vito Scaletta. This installment focuses on the beginnings of organized crime in Sicily, introducing new characters and experiences that help shape the Mafia’s foundation.
Players who expect to see familiar characters like Vito Scaletta might be disappointed. This because the game’s timeline clearly places it before Vito’s time in the criminal underworld. Players may have better luck with Lincoln Clay from Mafia 3 then.
Why isn’t Vito in Mafia: The Old Country?

Mafia: The Old Country is a prequel that delves into the beginnings of the Cosa Nostra in Sicily during the 1900s. This omission is mainly because the game’s story focuses on a different time period and a new narrative direction.
The Old Country follows a fresh protagonist named Enzo Favara and aims to show the early days of the Mafia, a time that happened long before Vito was even involved. Although Vito was born in San Martino, Sicily, in 1925, The Old Country takes place in the 1900s, decades before his birth. As a result, including Vito would be impossible from a timeline perspective, which would harm the game’s realism and storytelling consistency.
Additionally, The Old Country is designed to establish its own identity within the franchise by introducing new characters, conflicts, and locations to expand the Mafia’s history. Bringing in Vito, a character already strongly tied to Empire Bay and the Falcone crime family, might take attention away from the new protagonist and weaken the game’s intended focus. By making Enzo Favara the main character, The Old Country provides a unique look at the Mafia’s early days, separate from existing characters and plotlines.
Including well-known characters like Vito could lessen the story’s impact and restrict the creative freedom needed to explore new ideas and relationships. Leaving Vito out of The Old Country is a purposeful choice to preserve historical accuracy, keep the narrative focused, and maintain creative control.
Are Any Mafia 2 characters in Mafia: The Old Country?

There may be some characters who appear in Mafia: The Old Country. There is no clear confirmation that any characters from Mafia II will definitely show up in Mafia: The Old Country. Mafia: The Old Country is set as a prequel to the entire series, diving into the beginnings of the Mafia in Sicily during the early 1900s.
This time period comes before the events of Mafia II, which mostly takes place in the 1940s and 1950s. Mafia: The Old Country is a completely new story with fresh characters, a standalone narrative meant to expand on the origins of organized crime. Players do not need any prior knowledge to follow the main story or understand the experiences of the protagonist, Enzo Favara.
That said, the Mafia: The Old Country Community Q&A does mention subtle nods to the wider timeline of Mafia, and it notes that Game Director Alex Cox at PAX East suggested four characters might make an appearance in the gameplay of Mafia: The Old Country. This would be significant, considering how the game has been described.
One character from Mafia II who could possibly appear in Mafia: The Old Country, based on the timeline and setting, is Leo Galante. Leo’s backstory states he was born in Sicily in 1887, which would place him as a young adult during the events of Mafia: The Old Country, since it is set in 1900s Sicily.
In fact, he was born in the same region where the game takes place. Leo served as Consigliere to Frank Vinci, so it is possible that a younger version of him could have been part of the early Sicilian organized crime scene, potentially interacting with Enzo Favara, the main character of Mafia: The Old Country. Leo also had ties to Don Calò, the leader of the Sicilian Mafia. Still, we’re just speculating based only on his age and background, and not on any official statements from the developers.